Featured in Tax Journal: Barbara Bento and Antony Greenwood on HMRC’s assessment time limits
18 Nov 2026 • Insight • News • Tax Disputes and Investigations
Barbara Bento and Antony Greenwood from our Tax Disputes and Investigations team have written an article for Tax Journal exploring how far back HMRC can go when assessing historic tax, following the Upper Tribunal’s recent decision in Harte v HMRC.
The time HMRC has to raise an assessment normally depends on the taxpayer’s behaviour – it is four years as standard, six years where the taxpayer was careless and 20 years where an error was deliberate.
In Harte, HMRC argued that a single deliberate error in a tax year allowed it to apply the 20-year time limit to every other error in that year. The Upper Tribunal rejected this argument, confirming that each error must be considered separately, with the time limit determined by the behaviour that caused it.
Barbara and Antony consider the practical implications of the decision and also highlight the importance of understanding the limits of HMRC’s powers when challenging assessments for earlier tax years.
Read the full article in Tax Journal. Free registration may be required.
If you are facing an HMRC enquiry into earlier tax years, our Tax Disputes and Investigations team can help. Complete the form below and one of our experts will be in touch.
Contact us
We're here to help - whether you have a question, need advice, or want to tell us about your requirements.

